Imo there were equally really really bad for different reasons.
Josy's was just shallow and bland but Maya's was entirely out of place and such a bad timing, not intimate at all and in the middle of people, they didnt even kissed afterwards.
And Maya was not afraid of getting sick and the mc stopping to support her due to it, its the opposite, shes worried about the mc having to live a life like her dad patrick whos nothing but a empty broken shell at this point. She doesnt want tremolo to end up like that.
So his "i love you no matter what and will be there for you!!!" actually did nothing to disperse her fears and possibily even reinforced them. Its this utter dedication and devotion which did lead patrick to where he is after all.
Both of these ILY scenes were seriously so bad and underwhelming that im questioning if its by purpose and actually a bad move to tell the ILY in this episode already, only being able to say it to one of them reinforces that idea for me.
I really like josy and am looking forward to her solo path but i agree, i was utterly annoyed that josy is still in the "okay lets give it a try" (with maya) mindset. How long does she expect the MC to stay single wtf
And from a pure gameplay perspective i feel were starting to lack the time to properly explore the solo relationships with maya and josy on a non-throuple route. It feels more and more like the (breaking) throuple is the supposed way to a solo route with either of them.
Its kinda funny how as a player IN the throuple im annoyed that they arent finally getting over themselfes and make up and as a player OUT of the throuple im annoyed that they arent getting over themself and break up
its like the worst for both worlds
